Editor's Note: We were recently approached by Jennifer Herron, an enterprising mechanical engineer, with an intriguing idea of what really constitutes a 3D CAD design. She rightly posits that it's a 3D model, not a 2D drawing. Her thesis is the fact that there is a major disconnect between a perceived CAD workflow and actual workflow, largely due to a lack of standardized language, methods, and practices, regardless of CAD software used. In addition, she questions why are we still using 2D drawings to convey 3D designs when 3D models do a much better job? Below is her take on making standardization more practical through the use
of a common language for interaction and collaboration throughout the design process with what she calls model-based design.
There is a lot of ongoing confusion among CAD designers on how to take advantage of CAD software capabilities and consequently, Model-Based Design (MBD) is not winning any popularity contests. Adoption of MBD is stalled by the lack of methods and practices that standardize the design engineer's workflow. Designers are stuck when setting up, creating and delivering CAD models. They need a comprehensive set of clear standards and processes to maximize their software ROI and to collaborate and communicate with other members of their team using CAD models.
To that end, I suggest that we, the CAD community, go back to the basics and re-clarify the language we commonly use. In doing so, my goal is to facilitate the transition using discipline and organization to span the gap between 2D detailed drawings for manufacture and the 3D CAD revolution.
I invite those involved in the CAD community, to help me edit the definitions for MBD, in hopes of developing clear language for building hardware from 3D CAD.
Instructions for editing a definition
To provide an edit or comment for a definition, click on the send comment link under each definition. This will generate an email and send it to me. Please make your language as clear and plain as possible.
Click here to edit and comment the MBD Definitions
Model Based Design (MBD) - A development approach, for the design engineer, that declares the 3D CAD as the design authority as opposed to the 2D Drawings. The idea is to make the CAD models the source of the design database. This pushes a shift in the engineer's mindset to think of 3D CAD as THE deliverable document. 3D CAD models are no longer just a means to creating a 2D drawing. Rather, the 3D CAD model is the source of the design database and is the authority which all other outputs flow from (i.e. Finite Element Meshes (FEM), production drawings, bill of materials, etc.). While most will still use drawings for the manufacturing stage, the practice of MBD lends itself more readily to collaboration and interoperability, a future in digital prototyping and additive manufacturing and 3D digital work instructions.
Model Based Enterprise (MBE) - NIST and the DOD define it as - A fully integrated and collaborative environment founded on 3D product definition detailed and shared across the enterprise; to enable rapid, seamless, and affordable deployment of products from concept to disposal. More information is available at the Model Based Enterprise website.
Model - A mathematically correct three-dimensional representation of a person or thing or of a proposed structure.
Computer Aided Design (CAD) - The use of computer technology for the design of objects.
2D Drawing - Two-dimensional flat orthogonal representations of a three-dimensional object; used to convey detailed information such as dimensions, tolerance, materials, and construction techniques related to how an object is to be built. Both engineering and architecture organizations have standardized this communication method.
2D CAD - The use of CAD software to create 2D drawings, resulting in either printed paper or digital PDF. In many engineering environments the 2D drawings produced by CAD Software are the official specifications (design authority or record of authority) for finished products and are often generated from and linked to the 3D CAD.
3D CAD - The use of Computer Aided Design Software to create and view objects in three dimensions, i.e. a geometrically correct digital model of the object. The results of the process are saved in a digital computer file referred to as a 3D CAD Model. Most modern 3D CAD software applications are capable of generating the orthographic projections required for a 2D drawing and from the 3D CAD, changes can be pushed to the drawing as well.This model may or may not include PMI (Product and Manufacturing Information) data.
Drawing Standard - A drawing standard defines how to translate 3D data into a 2D format in a standardized method, so that all members of the team can effectively understand the drawing. This communication method includes: orthographic views, dimensions, tolerances, materials, revision history, company information, etc. This standard is well defined and used across many industries as the ASME Y14.5.
MBD CAD Modeling Standard - A standard that specifies procedures and techniques for building CAD models that enable effective implementation of Model Based Design to all forms of hardware products. The modeling standard is analogous to using ANSI Y14.5 for creating 2D drawings, but is instead applied to 3D CAD. In short, it is a standardized communication method for 3D CAD models, encompassing what to include in the model from fillets and threads to model translation techniques for analysis or digital manufacturing.
Add Definition - Don't see a critical definition? Feel free to add one with recommended title and definition. Click on the Send Comment link below.
Commentary By Jeffrey Rowe, Editor
We applaud and support Ms. Herron's effort for a consistent language that includes definitions of what 3D CAD and associated models are really all about. She's really only gotten started with it, but your input could prove invaluable to her effort and the larger CAD community.
A lot of what she proposes are extensions of efforts put forth by some of the standards organizations, such as NIST, as well as the DoD. Although it may seem a bit formal at first, it begins to make sense when you consider how vital communication is for collaborative design and engineering projects conducted by teams literally around the world.
Contrary to what we've been hearing for the past 10+ years, drawings (whether digital or on paper) aren't going totally away any time soon. But, isn't it about time that we exploit and capitalize on 3D models for what they are - the true end product from the 3D design process on the way to manufacturing that product in 3D.
Of the above concepts and definitions, I find one of the most interesting to be the Model-Based Enterprise (MBE) that is based on a product definition referred to as the Model-Based Definition (MBD). The MBD can be viewed as an annotated 3D CAD model that contains all the information needed to define a product. This annotated model is what replaces a traditional drawing. In this context, then, a 2D drawing is created as an exception not as a standard byproduct of the 3D design process. This makes even more sense in the context of collaboration and communicating a design further upstream as part of the comprehensive product manufacturing information (PMI) package.
So, whether you agree or disagree with Ms. Herron's definitions, comment on them. Consistent understanding and common language are huge steps forward for the CAD industry as a whole and its millions of practitioners. After all, in the end shouldn't the deliverable of a 3D design be a 3D model, and not a 2D drawing? Will these concepts and definitions take hold in the CAD community at large? It's really hard to say, but I definitely think it's a step in the right direction and a long overdue one at that - 3D in and 3D out.
The Week's Top MCAD News
At MCADCafé we track many things, including the stories that have attracted the most interest from our subscribers. Below are the news items that were the most viewed during last few weeks.
Dassault Systèmes Forming Americas Campus in Greater Boston Area
Dassault Systèmes has signed a long term lease for 320,000 square feet of new office, technology lab and data center space in 175 Wyman Street and 185 Wyman Street, Waltham, MA. This is the largest lease transaction in Greater Boston in 2010. Dassault Systèmes will move here to create its new Americas corporate campus. Dassault Systèmes, whose software brands include CATIA, DELMIA, ENOVIA, SIMULA, SOLIDWORKS, 3DVIA and EXALEAD, has outgrown existing facilities in Concord and Lowell, MA and will be expanding into this showcase campus for its combined workforce. They are scheduled to move into all of 175 Wyman Street totaling 211,741 square feet in mid-2011, and may grow into 185 Wyman Street thereafter. The Waltham location will initially accommodate 800 employees. Dassault Systèmes' current real estate portfolio consists of its global corporate headquarters in Velizy, France, approximately 40 locations throughout North and South Americas, and numerous other offices around the world.
Siemens PLM Software's New Machine Design Solution Provides Comprehensive Mechatronics Design Capabilities
Siemens PLM Software announced a new integrated machine design solution aimed at creating value for companies that develop and market machine tools and production machines. Mechatronics Concept Designer represents a paradigm shift for the industry with a new systems engineering approach to machine design that captures and, manages early requirements and facilitates the simultaneous definition and simulation of the complex mechanical, electrical and automation software found in today's machine tools. With an interactive simulation capability based on “gaming” technology, Mechatronics Concept Designer can help significantly reduce development time and improve product quality for the machine design industry. Mechatronics Concept Designer, which is based on Siemens PLM Software's flagship computer-aided design application NX software and works in conjunction with its Teamcenter, was announced at the International Manufacturing Technology Show (IMTS).
SME to Acquire Tooling U to Become Worlds Leading Provider of Manufacturing Knowledge
Creating a powerhouse in manufacturing work force development, the Society of Manufacturing Engineers (SME) and Tooling University LLC (Tooling U) announced they have signed a definitive agreement for SME to acquire all outstanding shares of Tooling U, a leading provider of online training for the manufacturing industry. The move is an important step in SME's strategy to become the unquestioned leader of content development and delivery, addressing the global and growing need for skilled labor. The substantial resources of SME's certification products, in-person training and webinar offerings will be combined with Tooling U's online training platform and more than 400 courses to provide the global manufacturing community with a comprehensive source of manufacturing knowledge. Educating the current and future manufacturing work force is critical for the health and growth of the manufacturing industry. The closing of the transaction is expected at the end of September, and at that time, SME will be the sole shareholder. Tooling U's online training complements SME's highly regarded in-person training and certification programs to create a flexible, on-demand, customized and content-rich blended learning solution.
Dassault Systèmes 3DVIA Introduces 3D Model Viewer for the iPad
Dassault Systèmes announced 3DVIA Mobile HD, an interactive 3D model viewer for the iPad. With 3DVIA Mobile HD for the iPad, users can access, view and interact with thousands of high-quality models hosted on the 3DVIA.com content warehouse with the swipe of a finger. Unlike other 3D model viewers, 3DVIA Mobile HD allows users of most 3D modeling software packages to connect to 3DVIA.com and share their work on the iPad platform. Users follow a simple three-step process: create a free 3DVIA.com account, upload 3D assets to the site, then connect with 3DVIA Mobile HD to showcase assets on the iPad. 3DVIA.com accepts content in over 30 formats, including 3DXML, .dae (COLLADA), .3ds, .obj, IGES, STEP and .kmz. Select modeling applications from Dassault Systèmes, including 3DVIA Composer, SolidWorks and CATIA, now publish directly to 3DVIA.com, making the process even easier. 3DVIA Mobile HD for iPad is available on the App Store for a limited time at $1.99 USD. After this time, it will be available for $4.99 USD. For more information, visit http://www.3dvia.com/mobile/. Key features of 3DVIA Mobile HD include:
- Interactive 3D viewer: pan, zoom and inspect models with intuitive iPad finger movements;
- Integrated 3DVIA 3D model search: search, download and view over 20,000 3D models published to 3DVIA.com;
- Compatibility with popular 3D formats: read and view 3D assets that you upload to 3DVIA.com in many popular formats, including .dae (COLLADA), .3ds, .obj, .iges, .step, .kmz, .3DXML, and many more;
- Save and export 2D renderings (images) to Facebook and e-mail;
- Private publishing on 3D models: restrict access to sensitive product information by publishing to your private account; and
- Interact with the 3DVIA.com community: comment on and rate 3D models from the iPad.
Jeffrey Rowe is the editor of MCADCafé and MCAD Weekly Review. He can be reached at Email Contact or 719.221.1867.
Product and Company News
Manufacturing Technology Consumption Up 58.9% in 2010
PE-WALLCHECK - Wall Thickness Analysis for Pro/ENGINEER Wildfire 5 and Windows 7
Autodesk Extends Inventor Publisher to Mobile Devices
American Italian Pasta Company Rolls Out Aras Enterprise Open Source PLM for Recipe Management
Android and iPhone Applications Developed for Aras Enterprise Open Source PLM
Autodesk Offers Students Free Three-Year Software Licenses
Ten Questions to Ask PLM Solution Suppliers A New White Paper from CIMdata
PLMIG Announces "PLM in the USA" Open Discussion
ZPrinting Helps Lab Identify POW/MIA Remains
Domespace Chooses SolidWorks Software As Foundation of New Online System for Designing Eco-Friendly Homes
Majenta Solutions awarded contract by Jaguar Land Rover for the supply of Autodesk Alias Surface software
InnovMetric Software's Web Site Offers New Section Reviewing 3D Digitizing Hardware
Bringing the Smart Grid Home with Help from SolidWorks
Uncover What's New in SolidWorks 2011
Scania Improves Its Product Development With Support From Dassault Systèmes PLM Solutions
Autodesk Signs on as National Sponsor of Cleantech Open
Dassault Systèmes DraftSight Now Available for Mac OS
Blue Ridge Numerics Launches CFD-University
Dassault Systèmes : AgustaWestland Chooses V6 for Production and Supplier Collaboration Excellence
Equipment Designed with Autodesk Inventor Enhances Mine Safety and Productivity
MSC.Software Donates Multidiscipline Simulation Software to Franklin W. Olin College of Engineering
DriveWorks Solo Awarded SolidWorks Gold Certification
Delcam launches fastest feature-based machining with FeatureCAM 2011
NorthRidge Software Develops Advanced Search Solution for Aras PLM Software Suite
Baotou Bei Ben Heavy Trucks Accelerates Engineering Productivity With MSC.Software
Virginia Tech Uses MSC.Software's Technology for NASA Fixed Wing Research
CimatronE to Introduce New Productivity Acceleration Device for NC Programmers
Innovative GagePlate System Enhances Master3DGage Inspection with Increased Precision and Volume
RapidForm to Interface Directly with Nikon Metrology Handheld Laser Scanners
Planit Acquires Significant Global Sheet Metal Business
Mecanica Solutions and FAB Solutions Announce Partnership
MSC.Software & Ingeciber Sign Business Partner Agreement
Gunslingers Get It Right For Edgecam
Mecanica Solutions Inc. and CADimensions Embark on a Partnership to Market 360 Enterprise Software-An Innovative Suite of Product and Business Automation Software
Radan Expands its UK Team due to Increased Business
Catalog Data Solutions CAD Download Solution Implemented by Heyco Products
RWM Casters Increases Sales Prospects With PARTsolutions 3D Part Catalog Technology
Toyota Caelum Uses Spatials 3D CAD Translation to Improve Data Workflows for Automotive Manufacturers
Tata Technologies Names Trident Tech Labs a Reseller of i GET IT and i CHECK IT
Knovel Introduces Aerospace and Defense Essentials
Scania Improves Its Product Development with Support from Dassault Systèmes PLM Solutions
Students Nationwide Invited to Tackle Environmental Issues at Third Annual Siemens Design Challenge
Design Through Manufacturing Takes Products from Good to Great
CDC Software Announces Availability of New PLM Solution for Ross Enterprise
Fatigue of Composites Comes of Age with New Product from Safe Technology
Hexagon Metrology Releases New ROMER Arm Products
Celeritive Technologies Signs Agreement with OPEN MIND Technologies AG to Integrate VoluMill into Award-Winning hyperMILL
ANSYS UNVEILS GPU COMPUTING FOR ACCELERATED ENGINEERING SIMULATIONS
Pointwise Offers Free License for SAE Aero Design Competition
intrinSIM adds tool path motion and simulation technology from ModuleWorks to Embeddable Technologies offering
NovaQuest Receives Prime Contract Award in SeaPort-e Program
Xradia Selects Canon Marketing Japan to Distribute Its 3D X-ray Microscopy Systems
3D Marketing Specialist TraceParts Launches New Corporate Web site
Nikon Metrology to deliver the most powerful industrial microfocus CT system in North-America to Chesapeake Testing
MecSoft Corporation Launches VisualServe Portal
LayerWise Breaks New Ground in Additive Manufacturing
Kalypso and Metafore Merge to Expand Innovation Consulting Services
Avatech Solutions to Report Annual Fiscal 2010 Results
GstarCAD Expands Distribution Channel in Philippines
GRANTA MI 4.0 Delivers the Best Ever Support for Practical Materials Information Management
Win a Free Creaform 3D Engineering Project
Schott Systeme Showcases CAD/CAM to the Asian Market
Dassault Systèmes Solutions Facilitate Ohio Northern University Student Simulation Projects
Stratasys Announces Seventh Annual “Extreme Redesign” Contest by Dimension 3D Printing
CADENAS opens its doors to Engineers of Mexico & Latin America
GstarCAD Unveils Whats New in v2011
Radan Expands its Team due to Increased Business
Related MCAD News
HP Delivers Private Cloud Solutions for Oracle Applications
Spatial Vision Logitech Bundle Makes 3D Vision Easy and Affordable
New Manufacturing Approach May Lower Solar Energy Costs
Boeing Begins Testing on 787 Dreamliner Fatigue Airframe
AMT The Association For Manufacturing Technology and Deutsche Messe AG Enter into Strategic Partnership
Tesla Motors Selects Aprisos Manufacturing Execution System to Accelerate Production
SGI Announces New High Performance Storage Platform
Materialise and Dr. J.B. Jupiter Explore the Power of Virtual Surgical Planning in Correcting Compound Wrist Fractures
HP Performance Series Monitors Quality and value come together
Berkeley Design Automation and MunEDA Accelerate Nanometer IC Analysis and Optimization
SAIC Awarded $11 Million Contract to Deliver Composite Building Material Manufacturing Facility
SGI Announces Support for Microsoft Windows HPC Server 2008 R2 on Octane™ III Personal Supercomputer
Ford and CenterPoint Energy Team Up To Prepare Houston Area for Electric Vehicles
SGI Announces Support for NVIDIA Tesla With High Performance GPU Computing Solutions
Collaboration Critical to the Success of Electric Vehicle Industry
Boeing Begins Assembly of 1,000th 767
Aberdeen Group Quantifies the Value of Enterprise Collaboration Solutions
Oracle Responds to HP Lawsuit
Mentor Graphics, GateRocket Collaborate on Integrated Solution to Streamline FPGA Verification-Through-Synthesis Flow
NASA Awards Boeing $1.24B Extension to International Space Station Sustainment Contract
Cloud.com Joins The HP AllianceONE Program
Boeing to Increase 737 Production Rate
Pavilion Energy Resources, Inc. -- Accelerating Wind Turbine Manufacture
Manufacturers Take a Step to Reduce Carbon Footprint
NVision HandHeld Scanner Helps Increase Life of Hydraulic Fracturing Tools
Frost & Sullivan Develops New Metric, the Velocity of Collaboration, to More Accurately Demonstrate the Value of Collaboration Solutions
HP and Oracle Reaffirm Commitment to Long-term Strategic Partnership
Solido Design Ranked Highly in DeepChip DAC Report
Boeing Military Aircraft Realigns to Position for Future Growth
Bricscad V10 for Linux released
Austin Energy Selects Autodesk Utility Design Software to Optimize Facility and Network Design
Energy and Carbon Management in Manufacturing Operations
Pavilion Energy Resources, Inc. -- Idaho Accelerating Wind Turbine Manufacture
HP to Acquire ArcSight
Tata Technologies names John Howaniec President PLM Solutions
PTC Names Jeffrey D. Glidden as CFO
Senior Lockheed Martin Executive Receives Distinguished International Aerospace Award
Gerald Hiller joins MecSoft Corporation as Director of International Sales
Manufacturing Executive Launches Manufacturing Leadership Council
Longview Advisors Announces 2011 Collaboration & Interoperability Congress
Alibre to Give Sneak Peek of Next Generation 3D Software at Maker Faire NY
Sixty Startups From Around the World to Showcase Tomorrow's Technologies at NVIDIA's Emerging Companies Summit
M2 Technologies Hosts Inventor Challenge Event: A 3D Modeling Face Off
Transitional Challenges from 2D to 3D - Giving Away Your IP
Tata Technologies Explains Nano Engineering Innovation At Conference
Maker Faire Detroit Returns to The Henry Ford, July 30-31, 2011
Newest Kroff Business Unit to Showcase Capabilities at IMTS
DP Technology Unveils ESPRIT 2011 CAM Software at AMB 2010
Delcam reaches 10,000 customers in North America
Lean To Green Manufacturing Conference -- October 26-29, 2010
GibbsCAM Highlighted in Mazak Exhibit at IMTS 2010
Konica Minolta Sensing Americas Exhibits At IMTS 2010
Hankook Delcam celebrates 1,500th customer at User Group Conference
PDM Migration Webinar-Expert Series Invitation
Intergraph CAESAR II Webinar to Discuss Pipe Stress Analysis to Address Advanced Design Requirements
VEX Robotics World Championship to Be Held at ESPN Wide World of Sports Complex on April 14-16, 2011
Delcam to host Middle East aerospace opportunities event
Majenta Solutions - Autodesk AutoCAD winter webinars
Advanced Volute Design, Full 360 CFD Plus Turbocharger Matching at Concepts NREC Exhibit During the 39th Turbomachinery Symposium
Milltronics to Use VoluMill Toolpaths in Demonstrations at IMTS
New version of KOMPAS-3D to be Presented at AMB Fair
Delcam to launch latest CAM systems at AMB
2010 CADWorx University Conference to Showcase Intergraph® Design and Analysis Software User Experience
Delcam to present developments in CADCAM for composites at IMTS
Intergraph CAESAR II Pipe Stress Training Scheduled
New CAM software blog kicks off at IMTS
Delcam to show high-precision manufacturing at Micronora
Delcam Newsletter - September 2010
You can find the full MCADCafe event calendar here.
To read more news, click here.
-- Jeff Rowe, MCADCafe.com Contributing Editor.